I typically buy the cheap drug store pencil eyeliners but i went out on a hunch and bought this No7 Eye Pencil in Black! And trust me when i say this is nothing less than fabulous! Its light not bulky but stands out perfect on your eyes. It is not smudgy and is really long lasting! Now that i have tried the no7 Eyepencil i would never go back to my old ones.This is high quality and very long last8ng and if your like me i have a pet peeve for smudging and this one did not smudge! I would highly recommend this product i finf it to be top notch and wouldnt trade it for nothing!

This is my 2nd time purchasing this eyeliner! It is AMAZING in SO many ways!!!!! BUT...I ONLY WISH THERE WERE MORE COLORS LIKE VIBRANT GREEN, BLUE, PLUM, GOLD....PLEASE MORE COLORS!!!!! This formula reminds me of Urban Decays & Sephora's eyeliner-it is extremely pigmented & creamy & stays put really well for me! Intense color payoff!!!!! Would make a PERFECT base for a darker eyeshadow to pop out! I've been able to work with it, QUICKLY though, to smudge out or lay down as a base before it dries! Great formula, Awesome price...Just wish there were MORE colors available!!!!!! Definitely recommend trying it at least once!!!

I truly love this eyeliner. Goes on smooth, last all day! As with others, I agree!! Needs a sharpener. Without one, this product is useless!! Please listen to your customers!!

I have been searching for eyeliners for a while now, and this product has been one of the better ones I have found. The reason it's only three stars is that I feel so much of the product was wasted. I had such a hard time using the sharpener, and because of that, I probably won't buy it again.

I have used this eyeliner for over a year! It’s the absolute best! Goes on silky smooth and stays on all day!!!! The only one I will use!

In my opinion the best eye pencil they have ever had. Easy to open. Sharpen the price point is at 9.99. You cant beat that for a good creamy eyeliner I would make it retractable. Less sharpening it looks good on any eye color. I'll be buying again

This is my favorite waterproof eyeliner to date. But after only a couple of uses I tried to advance the pencil and couldn’t. Not sure if it’s a malfunction or if I’m supposed to use an old fashioned sharpener? Either way I’m stumped because I really liked it?!

I have tried many eyeliners and this one is worth paying the shipping for. It does not smudge and looks wonderful.

Very poor quality. Does not wear well

I love everything No 7 so I tried some of the makeup products after I had discovered how much I loved the face creams. I love the makeup just as much! I love my eyeliner black and this color is very nice and it glides on very well